Gifts Under $5-Dollar Store Oven Mitt on December 9, 2013 Holiday gift under $5. Give a Dollar Store Oven Mitt filled with gift items. These make a perfect “gift bag”. You can fill them with kitchen utensils for people who love to cook, or fill them with hot chocolate for chocolate lovers and flavored coffee for coffee lovers. More gift ideas under $5! Peppermint Hot Chocolate In A Jar Peppermint Candy Cane Sugar Scrub Follow SEWlicious Home Decor’s board Christmas Everything! Holiday Decorating on Pinterest.